Friday, 13 February 2015

Why MOOCs will fail – they're not dating sites

MOOCs are not dating sites. Image via iStock

By Jason Potts, RMIT University

One of my Phd students is studying how parents make decisions about education for their children (you can participate in his survey here). We economists treat this as a problem of investment under uncertainty, which is to say that education is a bit like buying a stock, in that it has an uncertain future rate of return but a known upfront cost.

But it’s actually a harder problem than that, because unlike a stock, which will have dividends and hopefully capital gains, both measured in dollars, the return to education has many dimensions. Some are from labour markets and are measured with money, but other returns give rise to less tangible contributions to personal well-being along with broader spillovers to society. So economists have had to get good at measuring these total benefits and then using them to reverse engineer the choices people make about education.

Now I’m mentioning all of this because we’ve just noticed a fairly large hole in the case for MOOCs (massively open on-line courses) as compared to traditional bricks and quadrangles universities with expensive buildings and eye-watering fees. It’s this: the reason MOOCs will fail to displace universities is that, unlike universities, they’re not dating sites.

We make this claim based on some very recent work by economist Gustaf Bruze, who applies some clever economic modelling to large Danish data sets to generate very interesting and insightful findings about the “returns to schooling”. Specifically, he finds that “Danish men and women are earning about half of their returns to schooling through improved marital outcomes”.

The case for MOOCs has always been that they can deliver the same educational services, but at a fraction of the cost through the use of new technologies and business models. But this Danish study quantifies the extent to which educational outcomes are not the only valuable service that universities deliver – namely that a further and large component of the implicit demand for education is assortative mating – and MOOCs might not be so good at that.

In the economics of education, there are two broad explanations for the demand for a university degree. There is the human capital model, which argues that you go to university to learn things, and these things are like investments in capital, namely they increase your productivity, making you more valuable on the labour market. You invest up to the point where the cost of the education equals the expected return on your increased skills.

This predicts that by lowering the costs of acquiring human capital, MOOCs should increase the demand for higher education.

The other model is costly signalling. This argues that you go to university to acquire a signal to send to potential employers that you are smart and hardworking. You already know this of course, but employers don’t, and the problem is that anyone can make that claim.

So you have to do something that only smart, hardworking people will not find prohibitively costly. Interestingly, lowering the costs of a degree degrades the value of the signal. This will drive credential inflation, forcing the truly smart and hardworking to pursue graduate studies, or some other costly pointless thing, in order to differentiate themselves.

The private rate of return to higher education is not in debate here – it is substantially positive, with a wage premium around 60% over non-graduates and with an annualised return on the order of 10-18% – although as a recent report by Andrew Norton from the Grattan Institute shows, it does matter what you study.

What these types of studies tend to emphasise is:
(1) the importance of studying hard things, for example STEM subjects
(2) the importance of finishing them (called the sheepskin effect), ideally at prestigious places.

Now MOOCs might well be more effective ways of studying, especially of hard things. And MOOCs are tightly linked with some of the world’s most prestigious universities (e.g. here and here).
But are MOOCs more effective ways of dating? That’s the question it seems that no-one is asking. This matters because, as the Danish study shows, a large component of the return to higher education is due to better quality matches in household formation.

And if MOOCs are terrible at that (this is not a foregone conclusion; they may evolve to include local meetups, for instance) then that may well be the unreplicable competitive advantage (what investors call a ‘moat’) classic universities have.

This is not really the argument that most Vice Chancellors have in mind when selling their product (and paying my salary!). And it’s also likely that this private benefit translates into some social harm when assortative mating drives income inequality (see here, and here).

But the real story here is that those same Vice Chancellors shepherding their university’s enormous property portfolios might sleep a little easier knowing that these MOOCs are not going to eat their lunch and destroy their business model with their relentless cost advantages. Because MOOCs can’t supply the thing that Danish men and women, and likely Australian ones too, also want in their return to schooling – high quality matches not just with jobs, but with each other.

The Conversation
This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

26 comments:

Ranveer Patil said...

This is great do you have a catologue if so I would love one to share with friends and family.
U19 T20 World Cup 2016 Live Score
Watch India Vs Australia Live Streaming at www.starsports.com
IPL 2016 teams

Ankit Das said...

Want to know regular updates of Euro Cup 2016???? Venue-France,From 10th june-10july.... 24 teams,10 stadiums... Stay updated..
Euro Cup 2016 Live Streaming
Euro Cup 2016 Schedule
Euro Cup 2016 Fixture

jasmine kaur said...

india vs pakistan
india vs pakistan live
india vs pakistan worldcup
live
t20worldcup live
icc t20worldcup 2016
icc t20worldcup 2016 live
icc t20worldcup highlights
worldcup live
20-20 World Cup 2016 Schedule


jasmine kaur said...

T20 World Cup Final
England vs Afghanistan
India vs Bangladesh
Online Health Care Tips
IPL 2016 Schedule
Dhoom 4
T20 World Cup 2016
Ipl 2016
Ipl 2016 Schedule
IPL 2016 Schedule
IPL 2016 Match
IPL 2016 Draft
IPL 2016 Auction
IPL 2016 Live
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Schedule
VIVO IPL 2016 Match
VIVO IPL 2016 Draft
VIVO IPL 2016 Auction
VIVO IPL 2016 Live
VIVO IPL 2016
VIVO IPL 2016 Live Streaming
IPL 9 Schedule
IPL 9 Match
IPL 9 Draft
IPL 9 Auction
IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9
VIVO IPL 9 Schedule
VIVO IPL 9 Match
VIVO IPL 9 Draft
VIVO IPL 9 Auction
VIVO IPL 9 Live
VIVO IPL 9
VIVO IPL 9 Live Streaming

Anhi Dey said...

Mother’s Day 2016 Gift Ideas
Mothers Day 2016 Gift Ideas

Deny Games said...

This is a great web site. Good sparkling user interface and very informative blogs. I will be coming back in a bit, thanks for the great article. I have found it enormously useful.
bloxorz
cat mario
clicker heroes
cubefield
curve fever
dragon ball z devolution
duck life

Somnath Roy said...

Check out my site good mothers day gift ideas and surprise your mother on Mothers day.

Somnath Roy said...

To get all the latest news,rumors and gossips about Bollywood,just check fugomo.com

Social Gtf said...

nice article.......
website development company in delhi
website designing company in delhi
website development company in delhi ncr
website development company in noida
ecommerce website development company
website designing company in delhi just dial
jobs in web designing company in delhi
web development noida
website design delhi
Earthcon Sanskriti
Earthcon Sanskriti Noida
Earthcon Sanskriti Noida Extension

Falahhunn said...

best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE

xender for PC said...

thank you somuch shareit for pc andthis was thelove quotes great website imo for pcfor shareit for pc and for shareit shareit thisshareit for pc
download shareit for windows7/8/8.1/10
was the very best shareit for pc
download shareit for windows7/8/8.1/10
website xender for pc

Candy Sim said...

The blog or and best that is extremely useful to keep I can share the ideas
of the future as this is really what I was looking for, I am very comfortable and pleased to come here. Thank you very much.
strike force heroes| slitherio | earn to die 2
earn to die 5| goodgame empire |tank trouble 2

Khushi Sharma said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
Happy Friendship Day
Happy Friendship Day Quotes
Friendship Day Quotes
Friendship Day Images
Friendship Day Messages
Friendship Day SMS
Best Whatsapp Status
15th August Whatsapp Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Friendship Whatsapp Status
Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Independence Day Whatsapp Status
Love Status for Whatsapp
Nice Whatsapp Status
Happy Birthday Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Good Morning Whatsapp Status
Good Night Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp DP
Whatsapp Profile Picture
Parents Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Parents Day
Raksha Bandhan Whatsapp Status
Happy Raksha Bandhan Status
Rakhi Whatsapp Status

Khushi Sharma said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a website.Kindly check it out here
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Noida Extension
Galaxy Blue Sapphire
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza Noida

Khushi Sharma said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
couples halloween costumes ideas
funny halloween costumes ideas
halloween costumes Ideas for women
couples halloween costume ideas
cute halloween costumes
family halloween costumes
halloween ideas
good halloween costumes
halloween pumpkin
Happy Navratri 2016
Happy Navratri Images
Happy Navratri
Happy Navratri Wishes
Whatsapp Status
Independence Day Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp Status
15 August Whatsapp Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Good Morning Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Friends Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Good Evening Whatsapp Status
Good Night Whatsapp Status
Happy Birthday Whatsapp Status
Happy Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Independence Day Whatsapp Status
Happy Parents Day Whatsapp Status
Love Whatsapp Status
Love Status For Whatsapp
Nice Whatsapp Status
Rakhi Whatsapp Status
Raksha Bandhan Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp Profile Pictures
Best Whatsapp DP

Khushi Sharma said...


Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
India’s Independence Day
Independence Day India
15 August Images
15 August speech
15 August Songs
15 August Quotes
15 August Whatsapp Status
15 August Facebook Status
15 August Shayari
15 August Photos
15 August Messages
15 August SMS
15 August Wishes
15 August Pictures
15 August Wallpaper
Happy Independence Day
Happy Independence Day 2016
Happy Independence Day Images
Happy Independence Day Wishes
Happy Independence Day Messages
Happy Independence Day Quotes
Happy Independence Day Songs
Happy Independence Day Bhashan
Happy Independence Day Parade
RIO Olympics 2016 Schedule
RIO 2016 Tickets
RIO Olympics 2016 Medal Tally
RIO Olympics 2016
Olympics 2016
La Tomatina
Tomatina Festival
Tomato Festival Spain
Tomatina Festival
La Tomatina 2016
Halloween Costumes
Halloween Costumes Idea
Happy Halloween Costumes
Happy Halloween 2016 ideas
Happy Halloween Ideas
halloween store
halloween express
halloween decoration Ideas
sexy halloween costumes ideas

Khushi Sharma said...

Nice Article , I also have some topics visit them..............
Happy Raksha Bandhan
Happy Raksha Bandhan Images
Happy Raksha Bandhan Wishes
Rakhi Images
Raksha Bandhan
Raksha Bandhan 2016
Raksha Bandhan Greetings
Raksha Bandhan Images
Raksha Bandhan Messages
Raksha Bandhan Photos
Raksha Bandhan Pics
Raksha Bandhan Pictures
Raksha Bandhan SMS
Raksha Bandhan Status
Raksha Bandhan Wallpaper
Raksha Bandhan Wishes
Janmashtami Images
Happy Janmashtami
Krishna Janmashtami
Krishna Janmashtami 2016
Krishna Janmashtami Celebration
Krishna Janmashtami Facebook Status
Krishna Janmashtami Images
Krishna Janmashtami Messages
Krishna Janmashtami Photos
Krishna Janmashtami Pics
Krishna Janmashtami Pictures
Krishna Janmashtami Quotes
Krishna Janmashtami SMS
Krishna Janmashtami Wallpaper
Krishna Janmashtami Whatsapp Status
Krishna Janmashtami Wishes

Rimi Arora said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a website.Kindly check it out here
friendship quotes
friendship day
friendship day images
happy friendship day
happy friendship day images
friendship day quotes
images of friendship day
when is friendship day
friendship day messages
friend ship day
happy friendship day quotes
national friendship day
friendship day pics
friendship day wallpaper
friendship day photos
friendship day sms
happy friends day
friend ship day images
friendship day wishes
happy friendship quotes
friendship day pictures
Whatsapp Status
Friends Whatsapp Status
Friendship Day Whatsapp Status
Funny Whatsapp Status
Cool Whatsapp Status
Good Morning Whatsapp Status
Love Status For Whatsapp
Nice Whatsapp Status
Rakhi Whatsapp Status
Raksha Bandhan Whatsapp Status
Best Whatsapp DP
Best Whatsapp Profile Pictures

Rimi Arora said...

Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a website.Kindly check it out here
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Noida Extension
Galaxy Blue Sapphire
Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza Noida

Candy Sim said...

This is one of the cult game now, a lot of people enjoy playing them . Also you can refer to the game :
gold mine strike | pokemon go 2
The game controls are shown just under . Movement mechanisms primarily include acceleration and tilting controls.
stickman games | stick war 2 | animal jam 2

Denisa Cretu said...

Thank you for another wonferdul article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such an ideal way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such information.
Ciber Cafe 10a , Ciber Cafe 20a

Raden Ayu said...

wonderful model hijab terbaru
Model baju muslim pesta
model busana terbaru
modle fashion muslim etrbaru
tips media sosial terbaru
cek paket internet xl terbaru

prathap kumar said...

I have read your blog its very attractive and impressive. I like it your blog.

Javascript Training Courses | Angularjs Training in Chennai

prathap kumar said...

I have read your blog its very attractive and impressive. I like it your blog.

Java Training in Chennai Core Java Training in Chennai Core Java Training in Chennai

Java Online Training Java Online Training JavaEE Training in Chennai Java EE Training in Chennai

prathap kumar said...

Java Online Training Java Online Training Java Online Training Java Online Training Java Online Training Java Online Training

Hibernate Online Training Hibernate Online Training Spring Online Training Spring Online Training Spring Batch Training Online Spring Batch Training Online

Baztab Music said...

تور تایلند