Wednesday, 4 May 2016

Federal budget 2016: arts experts react



Joanna Mendelssohn, UNSW Australia; Jason Potts, RMIT University; Julian Meyrick, Flinders University, and Peter Tregear, Royal Holloway

Last night’s federal budget had little to say about the arts. The Arts Party described it as a “nothing” budget for the arts, while Live Performance Australia said it “fails to deliver any major new policy initiatives or programs” for the industry. The Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance, meanwhile, highlighted the fact that while the ABC’s base funding has been maintained, funding for specialist news services will be cut by A$18.6 million over the next three years.

So, what does all this mean for Australian arts and culture? Our academic experts offer their insights.


What happened Malcolm?

Joanna Mendelssohn, associate professor of art and design, University of NSW


We had such hopes for Malcolm: a Prime Minister who revelled in an excellent art collection, a cultured and witty man, who understood that the country needs to be intellectually nimble as it creatively innovates with the latest IT and scientific discoveries on the information superhighway.

Furthermore, here was someone who could address Q&A in his snappy leather jacket. As a graduate of Sydney Grammar and then the University of Sydney, he surely knew that an excellent education is a pathway to success, and to the country’s future prosperity.

Well this budget shows how wrong we were. Scott Morrison’s stern warning to those who keep the wheels of government turning is that the government is “continuing to keep government spending under control”. So nothing for the National Library, National Gallery, National Museum, Australian War Memorial or the Australia Council – which is already on life support.

The only infrastructure mentioned in his government speech is “roads, rail, dams, and public transport” – it gives a mental image of men in hard hats and high viz vests standing in front of earnest television interviewers for the tabloid news. The only difference between the Turnbull and the Abbott era is the addition of trains and public transport.

National arts institutions, along with the rest of the Australian Public Service, will suffer from an expansion of the so-called “efficiency dividend” from which “net savings of $1.4 billion will be achieved over three years”.

Probably the best thing arts organisations can do is to line up to give internships for “young jobless” as for the first time in living memory young job seekers are not being harassed but subsidised for their first chance of work. So while there are no regular jobs, it might be possible for embattled arts organisations to give a break to a school leaver.

And that is it for the arts – not very much at all.

What rhymes with ‘submarine’?

Jason Potts, professor of economics, RMIT University


The main thing that happened with the arts in the 2016 budget is that nothing happened with the arts in the 2016 budget. The arts and culture are obviously not to be part of this coming election campaign.

“This is not a time to be splashing money around” said ScoMo, and then didn’t, except on dams and trains and submarines. So much money splashed on so many submarines.

On the face of it, that’s good. It means that the new and existing models (e.g. Catalyst, carved out from the Australia Council) are being bedded down. Whatever you think of the new model, which has moved A$15 or so million into a centrally allocated program, this is now the model. So there is value in being ignored, in being made neither a priority, nor a target.


The main benefit, as I see it, came from the corporate tax cuts, small, but a good start. A healthy arts economy ultimately comes from private spending, corporate sponsorship and philanthropy, not from government handouts.

Anyway, someone’s got to paint all those submarines. Write songs about them. Make the movies and stories and evocative dances that show us as a great, nay proud and unrivalled, submarining nation.


A black and unhappy farce

Julian Meyrick, professor of creative arts, Flinders University


Beckett plays are full of nothing. Narratively, not much goes on. Spiritually, audiences lurch into free fall at the absurdity of human existence. There’s time to consider what you should be doing with your life.

A bit like this year’s federal arts budget, with Scott Morrison playing the part of Winnie, buried up to her neck in sand, or Nag, who has to spend his time in a box.

No doubt the sector will breath a sigh of relief no major cuts have been unveiled. There’s still the thumbscrew of the efficiency dividend (“4.9% in real terms from 2015-16 to 2016-17, and 9.5% in real terms over the period 2016-17 to 2019-20”) and a resulting stream of job losses undermining arts organisations large and small.

But at least the Australia Council has survived with its change purse un-raided and its arm’s length relationship intact. With decisions about four-year funding only days away, that will mean better sleep for arts practitioners across the country.

Still, let’s be honest, what was there to cut? One more slice from the “arts and cultural heritage sub-function” and there wouldn’t be much sub-function left to slice. As it is, the lack of investment in the sector is the culmination of two and half years of mistreatment, misunderstanding, and neglect.

No mention of the arts in the Overview at all (unless you include “support [for] a culture of ideas and innovation to encourage commercialisation, reward enterprise and facilitate investment").

Modern economics is a bit like modern drama. The jokes are black and the endings rarely happy. It works on a slenderising principle of “more for less” that can sometimes transmogrify into “everything for nothing”.

That’s certainly the kind of economic thinking the federal government favours. Rating: one and a half stars.


How much do we value ourselves?

Peter Tregear, teaching fellow, Royal Holloway


As expected, this year’s federal budget delivered no respite from - but also no dramatic furtherance of - the cuts to arts funding bodies and cultural institutions of recent years.

The devil, however, is not in this detail but in the failure, once again, to offer a compelling overall policy framework and vision for the arts in Australia. It is no surprise, therefore, to find no significant new arts programs or reforms in this year’s budget either.

While the Australia Council has, for instance, only had to cop an additional A$2 million cut (or around 1%) in its total outlay, overall this budget only confirms its fate to be no longer an arms-length policy and advocacy body for artists but rather a funding delivery mechanism for Government initiatives.

With no relief from their obligations to deliver multi-year “efficiency dividends”, our national cultural institutions, similarly, must now operate within severally limited imaginative horizons.

And yet, as Julianne Schultz argued recently in The Conversation, the fact that so much of Australian public life is now in the sway of forces beyond our immediate control only makes the civic role of these institutions “more important than ever”, lest our own imaginative horizons become circumscribed by images, shapes, and sounds chosen for us by global media companies with a product to sell, not a civil society to nourish.

Sure, the budget also outlines a growing expectation from the government that these organisations can raise more and more funds from corporate and private philanthropy.

But will those companies and individuals among us who have particularly benefited from this age of unprecedented creation, and concentration, of wealth be prepared to assist?

If government is increasingly unable to express much enthusiasm for the role of the arts in Australian life, why should they? Well, to quote Schultz again,
it is the cultural richness, the democratic, inclusive, pragmatic, egalitarian, highly skilled, educated and creative elements of Australia that make us attractive and distinctive.
Or, to put it another way, how much do we value ourselves?

The Conversation
Joanna Mendelssohn, Associate Professor, Art & Design: UNSW Australia. Editor in Chief, Design and Art of Australia Online, UNSW Australia; Jason Potts, Professor of Economics, RMIT University; Julian Meyrick, Professor of Creative Arts, Flinders University, and Peter Tregear, Teaching Fellow, Royal Holloway

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

47 comments:

head soccer said...

Hello, I am Lindaz Sophia. I like playing head soccer unblocked, I used to play these webs about big head soccer. Today, I introduce many web about sports head basketball as follows:
- Sports head soccer is a web game which has many exciting games.
- Besides, you can access a web big head basketball so that you play these games.
Have fun!

kalyan ram said...

Hello there,
You are doing just amazing work. I think it's time to change the layout of the blog.
Song Video Download
Video Download
Punjabi Song Video Download
Funny Video Download
Sports Video Download
Download TV Show Episode Videos
Dance Video Download

Falahhunn said...

best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE
best university in UAE

xender for PC said...

shareit for pc
shareit
shareit download
shareit for windows
shareit for pc
download shareit for windows7/8/8.1/10
shareit on pc download
shareit app
love quotes
imo for pc

pongal said...

Sankranti Wishes


Sankranti Wishes 2017


2017 Sankranti Wishes



happy sankranti wishes 2017

happy sankranti wishes



sankranti 2017 Wishes

bettycyoung said...

good and also tutuapp for ios is a wonderful method for accessing tutu app download approaches to hack or cheat in Pokemon Go however not much nice.

cathrynzbrown said...

good also uninstall the TuTu Application. Soon after effective tutuapp pokemon software program maintains upgrading their variation in nice.

Vaishali gore said...

Hi ! This is my first visit to your blog! Your blog provided us beneficial information to work on
ipl point table 2017
watch IPL 2017 live stream onlibe @ crictime & hotstrar

mcx free tips said...

The Federal Budget is morbidly obese and gaining weight every day. The Federal Government's inability to eliminate the deficit means that the national debt continues to increase daily. The only way the deficit can be reduced is by a combination of spending reductions and increased revenues. 100MCXTips.com

Cool Boy said...

Zapya for pc
Zapya download pc
Zapya for windows
Zapya apk download
Zapya for Windows
mobdro for Windows
mobdro pc download
Shareit pc Download
Shareit download
Shareit download
xender download app
xender app download
xender download for pc
Shareit apk Download
tubemate apk Download
tubemate

Crazy Boys said...


This is great movie of Hollywood you never watch before, Watch Annabelle 2 Creation (2017) Full HDRip Movie Full Movie

Watch Annabelle 2 Creation (2017) Full HDRip Movie Full Movie
Watch Annabelle 2 Creation (2017) Full HDRip Movie Full Movie
Watch Annabelle 2 Creation (2017) Full HDRip Movie Full Movie
Watch Annabelle 2 Creation (2017) Full HDRip Movie Full Movie
Watch Annabelle 2 Creation (2017) Full HDRip Movie Full Movie
Watch Annabelle 2 Creation (2017) Full HDRip Movie Full Movie

Crazy Boys said...


This is great movie of Hollywood you never watch before, Dunkirk (2017) full HD Movie Watch Online Full Movie

Dunkirk (2017) full HD Movie Watch Online Full Movie
Dunkirk (2017) full HD Movie Watch Online Full Movie
Dunkirk (2017) full HD Movie Watch Online Full Movie
Dunkirk (2017) full HD Movie Watch Online Full Movie
Dunkirk (2017) full HD Movie Watch Online Full Movie
Dunkirk (2017) full HD Movie Watch Online Full Movie

تجهیزات فست فود said...

nice post. keep doing :)

تجهیزات فست فود تجهیزات کافی شاپ تجهیزات رستوران تجهیزات رستوران تجهیزات هتل
راه اندازی کافی شاپ اسپرسو ساز

Expert for hire said...

I have to say that art is a passion, and many people will always view it as a way to express their feelings and also share information with others. This is a very nice post, a page that I believe is worth revisiting. Meanwhile, while you are busy with artwork, we can assist with choosing a topic for your research work. We offer the best BSc - Dissertation Topic Ideas which have greatly helped students choose the kind of topics that are very relevant and professional.

MyAssignmentHelpAu said...

Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information which I found very interesting to read. Need My Assignment Help? MyAssignmentHelpAu Provide best all Assignment Help to the student at cheapest cost.

Michael Jones said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Thank you for posting such a great article! I found your website perfect for my needs
video downloader online

Namita Verma said...

Tamil Girls Whatsapp Numbers

FirstAssignmentHelp said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice piece of information to us. This is very knowledgeable for me. I am John and i am offering Assignment Help to students of Australia and all over the world.

shahbaz said...

One of the greatest achievement is getting equipped with relevant and professional information, something that I achieved only after realizing that these kinds of pages shouldn't be overlooked. I love what I see. It's very informative.grey contact lenses

shahbaz said...

Here is the details of reception hosted by PTPI and it is specially arranged to recognize Mr. Gene Shirley.picture necklace

shahbaz said...

I really like how you compared the bowls of the “a’s” in part 2, it has a sleek look to it while conveying a message, and I think it was executed well.flapper dress

shahbaz said...

Here is the details of reception hosted by PTPI and it is specially arranged to recognize Mr. Gene Shirley.creality3d

shahbaz said...

Here is the details of reception hosted by PTPI and it is specially arranged to recognize Mr. Gene Shirley.Empregos no Japão

shahbaz said...

This is quite these days that you go and get followers for twitter account ,Well we are known to the fact that if you have enough twitter followers you should get retweet and likes.OTIMIZAÇÃO DE SITES

shahbaz said...

To delete a comment, just log in and view the post’s comments. There you will have the option to edit or delete them.trademark

shahbaz said...

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I truly appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your next post thanks once againOnline home shopping store India

shahbaz said...

I like that name “Learning Quest” and I imagine you get a ton of questions from students and parents about it. Which is great because great conversations are the beginning of great change.prometric exam

shahbaz said...

Fabulous artist. I want to see more paintings of this artist, She looks really good and arts just amazing. We should promote the talent maximum as we can.targeted traffic

Habibur rahaman said...

Bangla song, bangla robindro songeet, bengali robindro song Tomar khola hawa lyrics for all bengali song lover, this bangla song is most popular song to all bengali language user in the world.

shahbaz said...

To claim, in other words, absolute status for my values does not mean that I am being more righteous or faithful. In fact, ironically, if I claim absolute status for my values,convenio de practicas

shahbaz said...

Fabulous artist. I want to see more paintings of this artist, She looks really good and arts just amazing. We should promote the talent maximum as we can.chat

shahbaz said...

Hello,Thank your share! I’m very happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the accidental misinformation that is at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this greatest doc! picture necklace.Food Delivery

shahbaz said...

What a great story and it comes at a time of great success for Rollins…always important to be reminded of the foundation upon which we are built.magileads

Webroot.com/safe said...

Webroot Safe is a protection software solution that communicates with the cloud avoiding the hassle to manage the signature updates to deploy. Webroot Antivirus Download and Install for office setup visit www.office.com/myaccount

Unknown said...

Panchtantra Ki Kahan
Panchtantra Ki Kahani In Hindi
hindi panchatantra stories
Hindi Moral Stories
story in hindi for kids
Hindi Short Story
Moral Stories in Hindi
Story In Hindi

Amy Willor said...

A high-standard post with all imperative information about Assignment Help UK services. Looking forward to avail the premium services.

Siena Williams said...

We are proud of our best assignment help service by experts because of their dedication towards providing continuous support to students by helping them meet deadlines and scoring better grades. Hiring an expert to write your work is easy but hiring the RIGHT expert to get it done is a challenge. This is because there are a multitude of online academic help services and picking the best is always going to be a trial and error method. In case of engineering and pure sciences, the data analysis’ initial three/four steps remain the same. Only while doing research and analysis the structure is altered a little. Our thesis help providers are well adept in each of these structures, which is mainly evident by this information provided by them. However, there’s no reason to worry as you can just take statistics assignment help in Australia from My Assignment Services. We, at My Assignment Services, can put an end to all the stress and anxiety you face by taking the responsibility of your assignment from you.

shahbaz said...

Something went wrong I think its not complete article which is showing me right now. because I have read this article a few months ago and I remembered there were more paragraphs. I want to read it full again please if you have old version e-mail me…Bulgarian Lawyer

shahbaz said...

I think this is a great step to together all the countries in one platform. Russia, Ukrainian is our neighbours we should boost our import and export for success for the country. I really appreciate the Trump step.Companies formation in Bulgaria

shahbaz said...

Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.Адвокат в Болгарии

mycoursehelp said...

I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative! Thanks for the post and effort! Please keep sharing more such article. I've really like your blog and inspire me in many ways. We have already set a high standard for Coursework help.

Sunil Sharma said...

DOWNLOAD, INSTALL OR SETUP NORTON ACCOUNT
http://www.setupnorton.co.uk/blog/

shahbaz said...

I’m in my middle school. and love to bake. and I will come soon to William woods university if it will be possible, Because I like this one. and I’m also like you but i’m little sister in four of us. But my big sisters also like yours they always help me to do more interesting things as my second sister is a chef and she teach me a lot or you can say I learn from her forcefully. Because she never make me cry as I’m her little doll… So I enjoyed your story and Inspired to much from you….Love you..Bed and breakfast viareggio

Appsquadz Technology said...

Thanks for sharing this blog. A great information you shared through this blog. Keep it up and best of luck for your future blogs and posts. I have an important information regarding Web App Development Company. We also provide services like as Web App Development Company.

Babies R Us Crecit Card said...

Having a well out lined budget help in adequate planning and will lead to proper and effective management of scarce resources.

shahbaz said...

Hi, Your blog is so good. I really appreciate your blog. The way you write is good. I really love it. I hope you will publish the new blog that will be creative as usual.Medical Malpractice