Wednesday, 10 May 2017

Budget 2017: government goes hard on gas and hydro in bid for energy security


Gas infrastructure and exploration attracted the lion’s share of new energy announcements in the 2017 Federal Budget. 

Hugh Saddler
, Australian National University; Alan Pears, RMIT University; Roger Dargaville, University of Melbourne, and Tony Wood, Grattan Institute
The budget contains several measures designed to boost energy security, including: The Conversation
  • A$90 million to expand gas supplies, partly through increased unconventional gas exploration
  • a potential Commonwealth buyout of an expanded Snowy Hydro scheme
  • up to A$110 million for a solar thermal plant at Port Augusta
  • monitoring of gas and electricity prices by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission.
Below, our experts react to the measures.

Gas price problem far from solved


Roger Dargaville, Deputy Director, Melbourne Energy Institute, University of Melbourne


The budget contains a broad range of funding in energy-related areas, with a significant focus on gas resources, making A$78 million available for onshore unconventional gas exploration and reform in the gas markets, and A$7 million for studies into new gas pipelines to South Australia, from both Western Australia and the Northern Territory.

Interestingly, there is A$110 million in equity available (but not guaranteed) for a solar thermal plant in Port Augusta. And most notably, the government has proposed purchasing the Snowy Hydro Scheme from the New South Wales and Victorian governments, ensuring that the scheme stays in public hands.

The budget also includes A$13 million for CSIRO to improve energy forecasting tools, and A$8 million for the ACCC to investigate consumer energy pricing issues.

Overall, the budget highlights the government’s desire to do something about gas prices, but offers little to make a significant difference to a very difficult problem. Gas market reform and new pipelines are unlikely to reduce the exposure of the domestic market to price rises driven by international exports.

Importantly, there is little new funding in the budget directly relating to reducing carbon emissions and meeting the pledges made in the Paris Agreement (a 26-28% emission reduction relative to 2005 levels by 2030). Also noteworthy is the removal of funding for research into carbon capture and storage.

‘On energy this budget is small fry’


Tony Wood, Energy Program Director, Grattan Institute



The budget does little more on energy than endorse the government’s deal with Senator Nick Xenophon on corporate tax cuts, complemented by modest commitments to energy security, more gas and better regulation.

Government facilitation of gas development and beefing up the energy capability of the Australian Energy Regulator and the ACCC are simple logic, and the one- off payment to pensioners to help with electricity bills will be welcomed by them.

Major public funding for further feasibility studies is a little more questionable. If the gas crisis can’t galvanise support from pipeline companies and gas consumers for pipelines, why would governments reach a different conclusion?

And finally, one can only speculate as to why the federal government is contemplating buying out the NSW and Victorian governments’ share of Snowy Hydro. Presumably it is because the feds are concerned about securing support for the proposed expansion.

In summary, on energy this budget is small fry ahead of major policy decisions that rest on the forthcoming Finkel Review of the National Electricity Market next month, and the climate change policy review later in the year.

A step towards radical energy reform?


Hugh Saddler, Honorary Associate Professor, Centre for Climate Economics and Policy, Australian National University



Few announcements in the budget speech are more emblematic of complete policy reversal than the announcement that the Commonwealth would buy the shareholdings in Snowy Hydro Limited of the governments of NSW (58%) and Victoria (29%), to add to the 13% currently owned by the Commonwealth. This comes almost exactly 11 years after Prime Minister John Howard, responding to vociferous public opposition, pulled the plug on plans by all three governments for a public float of their entire shareholdings. What is more, Treasurer Scott Morrison has now announced that, once owned by the Commonwealth, Snowy Hydro would remain in public ownership.

This announcement of course accompanies the government’s Snowy 2.0 proposal, for a fivefold increase in the Snowy scheme’s current 500 megawatt pumped storage capacity (at Talbingo). This was used, after commissioning in 1974, to allow inflexible coal fired power stations to operate with constant output levels day and night, but is now almost never used. This presumably reflects commercial decisions by Snowy Hydro, as it trades in the National Electricity Market.

The rationale for Snowy Hydro 2.0 is to facilitate operation of a grid with a high share of renewable generation, by smoothing out variations in wind and solar supply. Does this announcement mean that the government envisages moving away from a strictly commercial approach to using the assets of the Snowy scheme? Is this a first step towards radical restructuring, or even dismantling, of the National Electricity Market?

Stronger legislation needed


Alan Pears, Senior Industry Fellow, RMIT University



The detailed A$265 million energy package includes a number of useful measures to strengthen the weak regulatory culture of the energy sector that has allowed our energy crisis to evolve. But it is still limited: strong legislative reform and active support of emerging competitors will also be needed. It is a modest investment compared with recent multibillion-dollar energy cost increases. If it is successful, it will deliver vary large net benefits to the economy by limiting energy price increases. Unfortunately, past efforts to fix the energy situation have largely failed to deliver real outcomes: we need clear objectives for outcomes, and a mechanism to implement contingency strategies if they are not achieved.

In a context of increasing urgency for stronger action on climate, and the reality that the global “burnable carbon” budget is very limited, investment to encourage more gas development seems misplaced. More emphasis on energy efficiency, renewables and smart energy systems would make much more sense. Energy efficiency already saves billions on energy costs and could save much more, while renewable energy is becoming cheaper than fossil fuel alternatives. They also help to achieve our climate targets. And fossil fuels are responsible for almost three-quarters of Australian emissions, so we need strong action to meet our international obligations.

The extension of the A$20,000 tax write-off for small business spending on equipment is a measure that, at least for small businesses, offsets a significant barrier to investment in energy efficiency. Firms will also be able to continue to claim the write-off to improve the economics of investments in on-site renewable energy and storage. Of course, the problem still remains for spending over A$20,000 by small businesses, and for larger businesses.

The energy security plan, which includes funding for ACCC to police energy industry behaviour is only a small step towards fixing the disastrous failures of energy policy and a transition to a 21st century energy policy framework. Much more will need to be done.

Hugh Saddler, Honorary Associate Professor, Centre for Climate Economics and Policy, Australian National University; Alan Pears, Senior Industry Fellow, RMIT University; Roger Dargaville, Deputy Director, Melbourne Energy Institute, University of Melbourne, and Tony Wood, Program Director, Energy, Grattan Institute
This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

21 comments:

Jens C. Kruse said...

Thanks

best essay writing service said...

Thank you so much for the great information.Substantial post. Really good-looking blog. A lot of blogs, I watch these days don't actually present whatever thing that I'm paying attention. But I'm most unquestionably attention in this one. I am in reality pleased with article excellence and path. This post marks on in helpful how some thought apply to any script point. Thanks a lot for protection enormous things. I am extremely a good deal thankful used planned for this place.

happy wheels said...

Thanks for your post! I believe there are many who feel the same satisfaction as I read this article! I hope you will continue to have such articles to share with everyone!
abcya

Lâm Tạo said...

Thank for your infomation in this post. làm mẫu lăng mộ đá

the reporter times said...

check it here https://www.thereportertimes.com/

Online Advisor said...

Rate and Review your Institute here: https://mapmystudy.com/review/university.aspx?cntryid=1&uname=Royal+Melbourne+Institute+of+Technology

html color said...

Thanks for the information you brought to us. They are very interesting and new. Look forward to reading more useful and new articles from you!

slither io said...

Good article, but it would be better if in future you can share more about this subject. Keep posting.

ahmed nomi said...

Visit us now to know
Top 10 Best Monitors To Buy In 2017

arsalan gujjar said...

Download Instagram Videos online with Instagram Video Downloader , all you have to is to paste the Instagram video url and then click Download button and the video downloader will grab direct video link

Johnson Charles said...

After a very successful first four seasons, the makers of Vikings are finally coming up with the fifth season. It will have some starcast changes and hopefully it is going to be even more exciting. You can check out the release date and the cast changes as well if you want.
Vikings season 5

Alice Taylor said...

Thanks for sharing the information. It is very useful for my future. keep sharing
http://word-cookies-answers.com

slither.io said...

Interesting article! Thank you for sharing them! I hope you will continue to have similar posts to share with everyone! I believe a lot of people will be surprised to read this article!

mahendar cherry said...

With all global companies looking to employ project managers, equip yourself with project management skills with AcadGild's PRINCE2® Certification, accredited by AXELOS
prince2 training course

244amaze said...

Showbox is presenting lots of contents for free. You can take pleasure in latest movies using Showbox app. It is enthusiastically presented for pc, get showbox for pc 2017 and other devices to watch movies and tv shows.

Ann Lily said...

Very great, I think I've found good article. I will see and consult some information in your post. I need it, thanks. hotmail login | hotmail sign up

Clara Lane said...

Government has taken wise decision against gas and hydro in bid for energy security and it is good to know that Gas infrastructure and exploration fascinated the lion’s share of new energy announcements in the 2017 Federal Budget. However I am CV writer and career counsellor at CV Folks where I help job seekers by providing CV services United Kingdom and career guidance with the industry specific CV experts. And love to read about economy related blogs and news which is connected to our life somewhere.

fb login said...

Thanks for the informations you shared!! I hope you will continue to have similar posts to share with everyone! I believe a lot of people will be surprised to read this article!
happy wheels

Indian Recruit said...

it is so great AIIMS Recruitment

Dung Maurice said...

Would you glimpse at this blog about phone monitoring apps

html color said...

Thank you very much for the information you shared, it's all I've been looking for